Firms urged to move away from ‘alarming’ boilerplate risk warnings to boost retail investment

The investment industry should move away from the widespread use of ‘alarming’ standardised risk warnings to encourage greater retail investment, a government-backed review published by the Investment Association (IA) has argued.

The Risk Warnings Review, commissioned by the Chancellor as part of the Leeds Reforms, published its final Supporting a New Retail Investment Culture report, outlining how investment risk can be communicated more effectively.

It found that current warnings were widely misunderstood, frequently ignored, and often deterred appropriate engagement with long-term investing.

The report argued that risk communications were most effective when they were contextualised, balanced, written in plain language, and aligned to different stages of the consumer journey.

Simple, accessible explanations of how investments can rise and fall, presented alongside relevant benefits and time horizons, were more likely to be read, understood, and trusted than blunt and less-focused boilerplate language, according to the report.

In light of its findings, the report outlined a series of recommendations that were underpinned by four ‘key principles’.

It stated that disclosure on risk should be contextualised and balanced; that clear and accessible language should be the basis for all communications; that statements in communications should be proportionate, credible, and effective; and that risk messages should be fitted to the consumer journey.

Alongside the report, the Risk Warnings Review published its Practical Guidance for Firms, outlining steps firms can take to improve how risk is communicated in mainstream investment promotions.

This included moving away from the standardised use of ‘capital at risk’ as a default and focusing on information that meets consumers’ needs, prioritises comprehension, and support effective, timely, and informed decision making around risk and reward.

Commenting in the foreword of the report, Economic Secretary to the Treasury, Lucy Rigby, said: “Our ambition, shared with industry, is simple: to make more people aware of the benefits of investing in a way that meets their needs.

“Through better information that captures both the risks and long-term benefits that investing can offer, we will support more people to achieve their long-term financial goals.

“We know that too many people have been deterred from investing by generic risk warnings that unduly warn people off from investing rather than giving them the balanced information they need to make an informed decision.

“This is a concrete example of where a culture of too much risk aversion is harming household finances, and it must change.”

IA chief executive and chair of the review, Chris Cummings, added: “For too long, well‑intentioned rules and industry caution have resulted in warnings that overwhelm rather than inform, discouraging people from taking the long‑term decisions that could strengthen their financial resilience.

“Our findings show a clear path forward – one where firms can communicate risk in a way that is balanced, contextual and genuinely helpful for consumers.

“In the months ahead, we will support firms to put the recommendations into practice, deepen our engagement with the FCA and industry partners, and continue testing what truly works for savers and investors.

“By embedding more effective risk communication across the consumer journey, alongside the upcoming Retail Investment Campaign, we can help build a healthier investment culture.”

---